If you spend more than $100, ground shipping is free to anywhere in the continental United States. If you spend more than $200, we’ll get your order to wherever you are in two business days—for free. And no matter what option you choose, your order will be automatically insured.

Gift wrap in our navy and gold trimmings is complimentary on every single order. If you’ve chosen to include a message, a hand-written enclosure will also be included.

Please allow us two business days to complete, pack, and ship your order. If anything you’d like is out of stock, we will contact you immediately and figure out how to get you what you need. If you need your order for a certain date, give us a call and we'll see if we can expedite the process.

For rush shipping or shipping to more exotic locales please see our rates below. Time estimates are in business days after the order is filled.

Your order    

  UPS Ground (between 3 & 7 days, sometimes quicker)

UPS 2nd Day Air

UPS Overnight

US Only





Shipping to Alaska or Hawaii


Flat rate of $35 for UPS 2nd Day Air.


The fine print:

*We cannot currently accept orders to be delivered overseas, but we invite you to come see us in the Ozarks any time.

*Orders scheduled for Saturday delivery are subject to additional shipping charges, but we will only arrange them at your request—in case of anniversary emergencies, impromptu proposals, much-needed indulgences, etc.

* Our partners at UPS do not ship to P.O Boxes. To get your package signed, sealed and delivered, we’ll need a physical address.

Keeping track of your package is easy:

If you have an account with Justice Jewelers, you can check on your order status at any time by clicking the “Orders” button on the My Account page. We will list your purchases in chronological order. For customers placing orders as guests, simply call us at 877-248-6790 and we’ll be happy to give you an update.



If the order you receive is not perfect for any reason, please feel free to bring it back into the store or send it back to us--within 30 days of your package's arrival. If you’re mailing a returnjust follow the steps below to ensure we can process the request.

1. Please note that the jewelry must arrive in pristine condition, with original packaging and the receipt—within 30 days of your purchase’s arrival.

2. Get a Return Authorization Form, either by calling 417-881-0551 during business hours or emailing Fill in the blanks.

3. Please let us know why you are returning it, to help us make service better for future customers or to make sure we tweak your order as efficiently as possible. Just jot a note a drop it in the box with the product.

4. You must insure your package. Postage is paid by the customer. Sorry, we cannot assume responsibility if a returned package is lost, stolen or mishandled.

*Send it to us at:

Justice Jewelers
3520 E. Battlefield
Springfield, MO 65809
Attn: Online Returns

The fine print:

*Custom order engagement rings and other special orders are accepted at the discretion of Justice Jewelers. See the “How special orders work” section below for more details.

*We cannot accept engraved merchandise for return. While we love initials and love notes, items marked with them are final sale.

*If you have any questions, just call us at 417-881-0551.

Once we’ve received the return, here’s what happens next.

When your return or exchange is received, our Master Jeweler will review the item(s). So long as you’ve followed the instructions above and the product does not show sings of wear, being altered, resized or damaged, we will accept it. We’ll then process your refund or adjusted order as quickly as possible, typically within a few business days.



We know that loving something and wearing it every day can result in a piece of jewelry becoming damaged or broken. At Justice Jewelers, every purchase you make comes with a promise to repair the piece forever.

If jewelry you purchased with Justice Jewelers needs some upkeep, send it back to us for evaluation. Our Master Jeweler will assess the piece and we will either fix it up in house or, often, send it back to the artist who originally crafted the piece. Making sure the piece gets the best possible attention from the most appropriate expert can take from 2 to 8 weeks and may involve costs for materials or labor.  

Here’s how to get the piece back to us for a repair:

Send your shipment to:

Justice Jewelers
3520 E. Battlefield
Springfield, MO 65809
Attn: Online Returns

*Include a note letting us know what needs to be repaired, along with your name, address, phone number and email address. If we have any questions, we’ll get in touch right away.

*If you have any questions, give us a call at 417-881-0551.



If you’re placing an order online, please indicate the ring size in the comments section when you check out.

If you’re coming in to the store, we offer complimentary ring sizing with any ring purchase. If you do not have your ring sized by our personnel, we cannot take responsibility for an inaccurate fitting. And if you can’t make it to our Springfield location, we advise visiting another jewelry store where you live to be sure you have the right size on hand when you make an order.

We also recommend calling to make an appointment for ring sizing if you’re planning on making a purchase during a busy season like Christmas. Lead time during the month of December can vary, please get in touch if you are on a tight deadline.

If you’d like to special order a size, request the size in the comments section as you would if it were in stock. Someone from Justice Jewelers will contact you to confirm when you can get your order and whether there will be any price difference for that particular size.



Certain artists that the store partners with can customize their pieces, altering qualities like ring size, chain length or stone choice. If you select anything differing from how the piece is shown online or in the store, we consider that a special order.

As mentioned above, we are happy to make any alterations that make you a happy customer. But special orders are returnable or exchangeable only at the discretion of Justice Jewelers. They also require a deposit of 20% of the total price when the order is placed. Custom orders often take between 2 to 8 weeks to prepare, depending on the workload of the artist. We aim to get these singular items to you as fast as possible. Get in touch with questions, we can you give more specifics on timing.

If the item you want isn’t in stock, we can often order it:

Every once in a while you may order something that appears to be in stock but may have been sold to someone else while you were shopping online or that may no longer be in our on-site inventory. If this happens, we will check to see whether the item can still be ordered from the artist. Fingers crossed, we can simply back order the piece and let you know when it comes in. Give us a call for more information and timing.